An undrafted free agent out of Kansas State in 2015, B.J. Finney has appeared to be destined for a starting role in the middle of the Steelers offensive line for years. Will he finally get his chance in 2020? That’s what we’re about to discuss.
Capsule Profile of B.J. Finney’s Career with the Steelers
After spending his rookie season on the Steelers practice squad, Finney made the final 53-man roster in 2016 and even started three games at both center and left guard. Finney has started a total of 13 games at center and both guard positions during his four years in Pittsburgh–including four at center a year ago–and the line hasn’t missed a beat. Finney was a restricted free agent a season ago, and the Steelers thought enough of him to place a second-round tender on him to the tune of $3.095 million.
The Case for the Steelers Resigning B.J. Finney
With veteran left guard Ramon Foster a prime candidate to be a cap casualty and Pittsburgh continuing to find financial freedom lacking, Finney would seem like the perfect fit to transition into a starting role in 2020. With Foster, 34, due to make over $5 million next season, the Steelers could net a savings of roughly $1.5 million if they can ink Finney, 28, to a deal that averages close to the $3 million he made in 2019 on his tender.
The Case Against the Steelers Resigning B.J. Finney
Matt Feiler is a restricted free agent, one that would likely command a tender that’s equal to or greater than the one Finney signed last year. Feiler, who started all 16 games at right tackle last year, can also play guard. Also, Chukwuma Okorafor and Zach Banner, both offensive tackles, earn far less than what Finney is projected to make next season.
Plus, one or both might be ready to start at right tackle in 2020. If that is the case, the Steelers, who started Feiler at left guard in place of an injured Foster in a game against the Rams last year (and not Finney), might feel that they can transition Feiler to left guard permanently.
Curtain’s Call on the Steelers and B.J. Finney
I think Finney has what it takes to be a starting guard or center in the NFL for the next five years. In a perfect world, he would just slide into the starting left guard position for the Steelers and there would be no drop off from Foster’s play. But this isn’t a perfect world.
This is a world where the Steelers must make some tough decisions, based mostly on finances. With so much money already tied up in the offensive line, they probably can’t retain both Finney and Feiler. At the moment, they have more control over Feiler than Finney. And that’s why I think they may have no choice but to let B.J. Finney walk as an unrestricted free agent.