Was the Steelers 2025 Offseason Really That Unprecedented?

The Steelers 2025 off season will soon end as the team converges at St. Vincents for training camp.

  • My, what a long strange trip it’s been.

Yes, the trip has been strange enough at times that the conventional wisdom heading into Latrobe is “These are not your father’s Pittsburgh Steelers” or “The Steelers Way as we know it is over.”

  • But should we accept the conventional wisdom at face value?

To be sure, there has been no shortage of personnel turnover since the Ravens ridiculed the Steelers in the playoffs. That’s certain.

But strip away the hyperbole and the social media-induced hype and you’ll see much of change we’ve seen is firmly grounded in franchise precedent.

Art Rooney II, Mike Tomlin, Omar Khan, Steelers training camp, St. Vincents

The Steelers Brain Trust @ St. Vincents. Photo Credit:Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports, via Yahoo! Sports

Stripping Down the D.K. Metcalf Trade

Strip the Situation to the Studs – Pittsburgh invests a premium pick in a skill player. He plays well. He makes an expensive veteran expendable. Alas, he has issues. So the Steelers send a 2nd round to the NFC and bring in a pedigreed player while shipping the former premium pick out.

Sounds familiar, right?

Good. Because it should. Except we’re not talking about how D.K. Metcalf and George Pickens came and went to Pittsburgh, but about the Bam Morris to Jerome Bettis switch out in the spring of 1996.

Jerome Bettis, Alan Faneca, Dewayne Robertson, Steelers vs Jets, Steelers history vs Jets

Jerome Bettis hurdles guard Alan Faneca evading Dewayne Robertson in the Steelers 2004 AFC Divisional playoff win. Photo Credit: Matt Freed, Post-Gazette

Yes, there are differences. Morris had legal problems; Pickens has maturity issues. The Steelers cut Morris. They traded George Pickens. They also didn’t fork over a ton of money to Bettis until after the 1996 season, whereas they handed Metcalf a check as he walked through the door.

Fair enough. But the template Omar Khan followed looks a lot like the one Tom Donahoe left behind.

Distilling the “Sleep Walking Through the 2025 Draft” Ditty

Distilling this Ditty Down to Its Core Details – Despite a desperate need at quarterback, Pittsburgh passed on multiple signal callers, waiting until day three to address the position, and opting instead to double-dip on defensive line.

OK. The heckles from the peanut gallery condemning the Steelers blueprint for their 2025 Draft class have largely come from the national media. But it serves to debunk the myth that this off-season was somehow “unSteelers-like.”

In January the Baltimore Ravens knee-capped a once-proud defense with 299 yards on the ground.

And Omar Khan responded in his third draft just as Kevin Colbert did in his second draft after the 2000 Steelers had similarly been embarrassed on Sunday Night Football by Fred Taylor: By beefing the defensive line.

Colbert passed on Drew Brees and drafted Casey Hampton (and Kendrell Bell) instead. Khan took Derrick Harmon.

Yes, a long-term solution at quarterback remains a glaring need for the Steelers. But in refusing to reach, Mike Tomlin and Omar Khan stuck with franchise precedent.

After passing on Dan Marino in 1983, the Steelers really didn’t have a shot at another franchise quarterback until Brees in 2001*  But more importantly, they always resisted the urge to reach for one (see the non-draft of Chad Pennington in 2000.)

*Unless you count passing on Steve Young in the 1985 Supplemental Draft or maybe Brett Favre in the 1991 Draft.)

Oh, And About the Steelers Quarterback Situation… 

Breaking the Story Down to Its Bare Bones: The Steelers had a young signal caller who was reaching unrestricted free agency for the first time. They wanted him back. They made him an offer. The New York Jets offered more. The Steelers declined to begin a bidding war.  Instead, they opted to go with a quarterback room that consisted of a veteran journeyman, a 6th round pick and a Wild Card nearing one of the endpoints of his career timeline.

That about describes what happened, doesn’t it?

Neil O'Donnell, Barry Foster

Yes it does. It is exactly how the Steelers quarterback situation unfolded in 1996 after Super Bowl XXX. They made Neil O’Donnell an offer. The Jets offered him more. The Steelers let him walk and instead turned to Mike Tomczak, Jim Miller (a 6th round pick) and Kordell Stewart.

  • Of course the analogy’s imperfect.

Tomzack, Miller and Stewart were part of the 1995 Steelers. Mason Rudolph, Will Howard and Aaron Rodgers were not Pittsburgh Steelers in 2024. While the Tomzack-Rudolph comparison holds water pretty well, Miller had 2 years and appearances in 3 NFL games, whereas Howard’s a rookie.

  • But the Kordell-Rodgers parallel holds up better than you think.

Kordell knew how to make headlines. So does Rodgers. Kordell had just played his first year. Rodgers has basically said this is his last. Kordell was a wild card that could go either way for the Steelers in 1996, just as Rodgers is now.

“Oh, but none of the QBs in 1996 caused the angst that Rodgers caused,” the chorus protests!

Angst for who?

Did Pittsburgh panic when Justin Fields priority boarded for New York? Did start a bidding war? Did they throw a contract at Russell Wilson after he visited the Browns and the Giants? Did they sacrifice future drafts to get Jaxson Dart? Did they reach for Shedeur Sanders?

No, they didn’t.

The Steelers had a plan at quarterback. And when that plan didn’t unfold as expected, they remained patient, refused to panic and, arguably, got the best quarterback available this off-season. And they’ll pay him 21.8 million less than the Browns are paying Deshaun Watson this year.

Its almost hard not to picture Mike Tomlin laughing to himself as he watched the social media outbursts that erupted as each day pass without Aaron Rodgers signing.

Putting the Steelers 2025 Off Season in Perspective

The Steelers 2025 off-season certainly had its share of surprises. And it is certain that neither Omar Khan nor anyone else on the South Side had a WWTDD? (as in What Would Tom Donahoe Do?) moment this spring.

But if you look at the principles that guided the Steelers braintrust through it all, you’ll see that they’re the same ones that the franchise has followed since Dan Rooney assumed control in the mid-60s: Try to field the best team possible for the coming season without sacrificing their ability to compete in future seasons.

  • Now, will their strategy succeed?

Its almost time to hit the blocking sleds and St. Vincents and start finding out!

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Thank You: Minkah Fitzpatrick’s Steelers Career and Legacy at a Glance

Minkah Fitzpatrick’s Steelers career ended exactly as it started: As a complete surprise.

In September 2019 while traveling on business in San Francisco an update flashed across the SteelersTres60 WhatsApp group announcing that the Steelers had traded their first round pick in the 2020 NFL Draft to the Miami Dolphins for Minkah Fitzpatrick.

Surely, this must be a false, this skeptical scribe concluded.

But it wasn’t. The trade was real and a sign that “The Steelers Way” was evolving. So I wasn’t quite as skeptical when the same SteelersTres60 WhatsApp group posted that Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith were soon to be Steelers.

But I never expected the cost of Ramsey and Smith’s tickets to Pittsburgh would be Minkah Fitzpatrick. But in Pittsburgh they are, and Minkah has returned to Miami.

Today we take a look at Minkah’s contribution as a Pittsburgh Steeler.

Minkah Fitzpatrick, Kameron Kelly, Mark Barron, Steelers vs Rams, Minkah Fitzpatrick's Steelers career

Minkah Fitzpatrick celebrates after returning a fumble for a touchdown. Photo Credit: Barry Reeger, Penn-Live

2019: Best 3 Game Stretch by a Steelers DB?

Minkah Fitzpatrick became an immediate starter and logged an interception 11 minutes into the first quarter of his first game against the 49ers. The Steelers lost in San Francisco that day, but Minkah flashed his calling card: Making dramatic, game-changing plays.

Fitzpatrick was quiet for the next three weeks, “only” deflecting two passes. But soon he would strike fear into the hearts of opposing quarterbacks and offensive coordinators.

People forget, but Mason Rudolph looked shaky against the Dolphins early in his first game back following his concussion. A Rudolph interception set up an easy touchdown for Miami, and the Dolphins put up 14 unanswered points in the first quarter as the Steelers struggled.

Minkah Fitzpatrick intercepted Ryan Fitzpatrick at the 11:14 mark of the 2nd quarter, and 13 plays later the Rudolph was hitting Diontae Johnson to get the Steelers into the end zone to cut Miami’s lead to 4.

Minkah, Fitzpatrick, Minkah Fitzpatrick interception Dolphins, Steelers vs Dolphins MNF

Minkah Fitzpatrick 2nd interception against the Dolphins. Photo Credit: Barry Reeger, PennLive

The Steelers struggled out of the gate to start the 2nd half, as Chris Boswell missed a 54 yarder.

Miami’s offense never had a chance to capitalize. Ryan Fitzpatrick misfired deep on his first two throws, but he found Minkah Fitzpatrick for his third one. 13 plays later Rudolph found JuJu Smith-Schuster in the end zone to put the Steelers up for good.

A week later against the Colts, the Steelers were in a tighter spot late in the first half as the 2-minute warning loomed. Indianapolis had a 10 to 3 lead that they were on the verge of transforming into a 17 to 3 lead. Minkah Fitzpatrick thought otherwise:

The Steelers beat the Colts that day, 26 to 24, with Minkah Fizpatrick authoring what was, at a minimum, 10 10-point swing in Pittsburgh’s favor.

A week later, against the Los Angeles Rams, Mason Rudolph had just made a field-flipping play to James Washington with 2:26 left to go in the first half, only to have Washington fumble. The game was tied and the Rams had a golden opportunity to seize the lead going into half time.

Two plays later, Javon Hargrave strip-sacked Jared Goff as Minkah Fitzpatrick scooped up the loose ball and streamed 46 yards to the end zone.

The play put the Steelers up 14 to 7, the last points the offense would see until Chris Boswell tacked on three with just over two minutes left to play. Oh, Los Angeles did attempt a comeback, but it was stopped after Robert Woods got past Joe Haden only to have Minkah Fitzpatrick intercept his pass with 20 seconds remaining to preserve the 17-12 victory.

The Pittsburgh Steelers have sent Jack Butler, Mel Blount, Donnie Shell, Rod Woodson and Troy Polamalu to Canton to represent their secondary in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

But in weeks 7, 8 and 9 of the 2019 season, Minkah Fitzpatrick may have authored the best 3 game stretch of any Steelers defensive back in history.

2020 through 2022 – Minkah Magic When The Steelers Need

Quarterbacks noted Minkah Fitzpatrick’s prowess and avoided him like the plague. Still, he scored the Steelers first touchdown against Cleveland with a pick six of Baker Mayfield in the 2020 home win over Cleveland.

As the true great ones do, Minkah Fitzpatrick displayed a knack for making timely plays at critical junctures in games.

In week 8 of the 2020 season, at the two-minute warning Lamar Jackson tried to tuck and run with it at the Steelers 3. HE made it two yards before Fitzpatrick stoned him forcing a fumble, which Robert Spillane recovered.

Minkah Fitzpatrick, Willie Snead, Justin Tucker, Steelers vs Ravens

Minkah Fitzpatrick knocks the ball away from Wille Snead. Photo Credit: Patrick Smith, Getty Images via Fansided.com

He wasn’t done. The Steelers couldn’t kill the clock. Jackson moved the Ravens to just outside Pittsburgh’s 23, where, with 5 seconds left he had Willie Snead open in the end zone, only for Minkah to step in and deflect the pass.

Minkah Fitzpatrick, Steelers vs Cowboys

Minkah Fitzpatrick after saving the day for the Steelers. Photo Credit: Boston Globe.

A week later against Dallas, he did it again, opening the 4th quarter against Dallas with an interception. Again, ended the Cowboys comeback attempt with a pass deflection over CeeDee Lamb in the end zone with 4 seconds remaining.

  • Fitzpatrick added two more picks against Jacksonville two weeks later.

In 2021 Fitzpatrick “only” had two interceptions, but he made those count, negating a would-be Ravens touchdown early in the game with an end zone pick and a game the Steelers would win 19-18, thus helping Ben Roethlisberger win his final game against Lamar Jackson.

2022 was a rough year for the Steelers, but they started it with a bang. Cam Heyward sacked Joe Burrow in week one on Cincinnati’s first play from scrimmage. Not one to be upstaged, Minkah did this on the next play:

Fitzpatrick started fast and finished strong that day. When the Bengals tied the game with 4 seconds left in the 4th quarter, Fitzpatrick didn’t fret – he fought back:

And thus the Steelers stole one from Burrow and the Bengals in overtime.

2022 was Minkah Fitzpatrick’s best season with the Steelers, as he logged additional 5 more interceptions, including victory sealers against the Falcons and then against the Ravens, the latter one coming on the heels of the “Kenny F__ing Pickett” comeback. He also batted away 11 passes, earning first team AP All Pro Honors.

Minkah Fitzpatrick, Steelers vs Ravens, Steelers vs Ravens 2022 M&T Bank Stadium

Minkah Fitzpatrick with the game-sealing pick. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune Review

From 2020 to 2022, whenever the Steelers needed it, Minkah Magic delivered.

2023 and 2024, Fitzpatrick Is Seen Less than He’s Heard

Using conventional metrics, Minkah Fizpatrick’s play dipped in 2022 and 2023. He only had one interception in that two-season span. He defensed a total of 7 passes in the two seasons, or the same number that he logged in 2021.

  • Pundits in some quarters rushed to conclude at, at age 29, Fitzpatrick was slowing a step.

But as Derrick Bell from Steelers Now pointed, out while we may not have heard much from Minkah Fitzpatrick, opposing quarterbacks saw him and shifted their targets accordingly.

In 2024 the Steelers defense boasted the NFL’s 2nd best 3rd down percentage, and in Bell’s estimation, how Mike Tomlin and Teryl Austin chose to deploy Fitzpatrick helped that happen. In breaking down a critical third down stop from the 2024 home win over the Ravens, Bell concludes:

This play results in a scramble drill turned prayer down the field, with the defense getting off the field on third down against the league’s best offense. These turn-downs aren’t a statistic that is measured like interceptions, stops, or forced incompletions, but having strong enough hook play to erase these beaters is crucial nonetheless.

So no one should mistake them missing splash plays from Minkah’s game recently for a lack of impact.

Minkah Fitzpatrick Trade = Cost-Benefit Calculation

Success in the NFL hinges on getting the most bang for your salary cap buck. Salarycaponomics alone indicate that mega contracts are more wisely invested in cornerbacks than in safeties. Throwing in Jonnu Smith makes this trade is a no-brainer – on paper.

Early in the off season, Steel City Insider’s Matt C. Steel argued for the Steelers to follow Philly’s blueprint and play more Cover 4. As Steel explains, “Besides a big, strong defensive front with depth, ideally, you want three corners who can cover.” Ramsey, alongside Joey Porter Jr. and Darius Slay gives the Steelers that third corner.

Troy Polamalu, Minkah Fitzpatrick, Pittsburgh Steelers, St. Vincents

Two safeties @ St. Vincent’s. Photo Credit: Steelers.com

Fair enough.

The Philadelphia Eagles did something in route to victory in Super Bowl LIX that no one else has done: Make Patrick Mahomes look mortal. If the exchanging Ramsey for Fitzpatrick elevates the Steelers defense to that level, sign me up.

But Minkah Fitzpatrick was always class act in Pittsburgh and a leader both on and off the field. It says here that not only is Minkah Fitzpatrick not past his prime, his best days may be yet to come. And if that’s the case, it will be a shame that he ends up not playing them in a Pittsburgh Steelers uniform.

But so be it. Thank you Minkah Fitzpatrick.

Thank you for giving Steelers Nation Hall of Fame caliber play in the secondary not seen since the days when Polamalus and Woodsons wore the Black and Gold.

I wish you the best.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

3 Takeaways as Steelers Trade Minkah Fitzpatrick for Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith

Last week the Pittsburgh Steelers shocked the world by trading Minkah Fitzpatrick to the Miami Dolphins for All Pro cornerback Jalen Ramsey and Pro Bowl tight end Jonnu Smith. The Steelers also sent their 5th round pick from the 2027 NFL Draft to Miami and got the Dolphins’ 7th rounder.

No one apparently told Omar Khan and Mike Tomlin that this was supposed to be the slow spot in the NFL’s off season.

While rumors had tied the Steelers to trades for Ramsey and Smith, trading Minkah Fitzpatrick was unimaginable. But traded he has been.

Steel City Insider’s Jim Wexell perhaps summed it up the best by concluding, “…Dolphins made off with the best player in the big trade with the Steelers, but that the Steelers won the trade.”

ON paper, Wexell’s right, we’ll see if what happens on the field vindicates his conclusion. While we wait for that reality to play out, here are three things this trade is telling us now.

Antonio Brown, Jalen Ramsey, Ramon Foster, Steelers vs Jaguars, Antonio Brown vs Jalen Ramsey

Antonio Brown vs Jalen Ramsey. Photo Credit: Karl Rosner, Steelers.com

1. The Steelers Brain Trust Takes 2024’s Meltdown Seriously

The 2024 Steelers closed their season with a 5-game losing streak that got uglier with each week. The piss-poor performance of the defense against the Chiefs at Christmas and in the playoffs against the Ravens called into question the franchise’s fundamental strategy of using defense to keep the team competitive until they can find a franchise QB.

Instead, Patrick Mahomes terrorized the Steelers defense through the air, while Lamar Jackson and Derrick Henry ridiculed them on the ground. In simple terms:

  • The Steelers defense got its ass kicked. Twice.
  • The men in Black and Gold didn’t belong on the same field.

No one should think, let alone suggest, that Minkah Fitzpatrick was responsible for these losses or even that he was some sort of “weak link.” That’s both wrong and disrespectful.

But Mike Tomlin and Omar Khan have clearly concluded that Jalen Ramsey can be a bigger part of the solution than Fitzpatrick.

Events may prove them wrong, but no one can say the Steelers took these beatings sitting down.

2. The Steelers Way Evolves Under Omar Khan

While this easily amounts to the biggest trade in franchise history, let’s keep it in context:

But they’ve never exchanged All Pros. Perhaps it’s true that a trade of this magnitude would have been near unthinkable in June of 2015, it hardly spells the death of “Steelers Way.”

  • The “Steelers Way” is simply evolving.

In fact, Omar Khan is building on tendencies that first surfaced under Kevin Colbert. Colbert began making trades more frequently in hopes of “Reloading with Roethlisberger,”  contract restructures became more common, and using voidable years on contracts began to happen and so forth.

Like Kevin Colbert and Tom Donahoe before him, Omar Khan is leaving is own finger prints on the Steelers Way. Donahoe pioneered the strategy of avoiding free agency bidding ways in favor of resigning your own players.

Kevin Colbert, unlike Donahoe, welcomed back players who’d departed via free agency, improved performance in the first round while displaying an uncanny knack for finding undrafted rookie free agent gems (you may have heard of Willie Parker, James Harrison and Ramon Foster.)

Omar Khan, Steelers General Manager, Kevin Colbert

Omar Khan and Kevin Colbert at St. Vincents. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune-Review

And while Khan has been more aggressive with trades and free agency, let’s also remember that he has a freedom that Kevin Colbert never enjoyed – roster building without having to manage the salary cap complications of a franchise quarterback.

3. The Steelers are NOT “All In” on Going for a Super Bowl in 2025

Before the smoke even cleared on Fitzpatrick for Ramsey-Smith trade, Everyone and His Brother in football rushed to the same conclusion:

  • The Steelers are All In on a going for a Super Bowl in 2025.

That’s the easy conclusion when you look at the D.K. Metcalf trade, Aaron Rodgers signing and now the Minkah Fitzpatrick trade. But as is so often the case in life, the quick and easy conclusion is the wrong one.

  • Yes, these splash personnel moves have generated a lot of Sound and Fury.

But you know what? The Steelers still have a projected 12 picks in the 2026 NFL Draft, they’re only missing a 6th round pick in the 2027 NFL Draft, and they’re still league leaders in available salary cap space for 2026 and 2027. They’ll lose a little of that leadership after they resign T.J. Watt, but the Steelers salary cap health will remain strong once that deal is done.

  • That’s the opposite of being “All In.”
  • Going “All In” means you’ve bet everything on the risk you’re taking.

For example, the Steelers were “All In” on Ben Roethlisberger’s recovery after trading for Fitzpatrick in 2019. The trade cost them a shot at a franchise quarterback in the 2020 NFL Draft, and impacted the next several drafts.

In contrast, if these moves result in another “muh” season that ends at about .500 but with no playoff success, the franchise will still enter 2026 with all of its options open.

If the Steelers were truly “All In” this would not be the case.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

4 (Not So) Random Reflections on Aaron Rodgers’ & The R Word

In case you’ve been hiding under a rock, last week Aaron Rodgers went on the Pat McAfee show and told everyone what they already knew – that the 2025 season with the Steelers will likely be his last.

  • And of course that’s all anyone in Steelers Nation was talking about.

Here are four (not so) random reflections on Aaron Rodgers and the R word

Aaron Rodgers, Aaron Rodgers Pittsburgh Steelers

Aaron Rodgers 1st practice with the Steelers. Photo Credit: Karl Roser, Steelers.com

1. And This is Supposed to News?

So how is it that a 20 year NFL veteran and 41 year old quarterback saying that the coming season will likely be his last qualifies as “news.”

HAD Rodger had said he wanted to play “a couple-of-three or so more seasons,” THAT would have been news. Instead, he told us what we knew, and we ended up talking about it for week.

  • There’s no secret as to why.

The NFL’s media ecosystem has a voracious need for page visits, clicks and podcast/video views that demands to be fed. Hence, a 41 year old quarterback saying he’ll probably retire after 17 weeks of getting hit by 300 pound plus 20 something is now “news.”

2. The Story Line Is Set

Credit former Steelers offensive lineman Trai Essex for saying the quiet part out loud:

One way or another, the story line is set.

If Rodgers struggles out of the gate, it will be, “…its pretty obvious that Rodgers should have listened to his inner voice and gotten on with his ‘Life’s Work.’”

If Rodgers starts OK then hits a midseason slump the “…after starting strong in September, Rodgers struggles began as twilight became scarce, as the changing colors of the leaves signaled that they, like Rodgers would soon be moving on to something else.”

Or, if Rodgers, like Russell Wilson before him, should play well until fading down the stretch they’ll say, “….as Myles Garrett threw him down for a third and final time on the turf at Cleveland, the look on Rodgers’ face said it all, ‘he’d clearly wishes was spending the holidays in Malibu instead of Cleveland.’”

And this will happen independent of what comes out of Rodgers’ mouth. Rest assured, the slightest stray comment that even hits at a smidge of frustration on Rodger’s part will be magnified 10 times over to fit the “Rodgers wishes he’d retired instead of playing” narrative.

You’d better believe that commentators such as Mike Jones, Andrew Fillipponi and Tim Benz have this quote bookmarked, and will trot as soon as an opportunity presents itself.

So be it.

3. Consider the Alternative

Imagine, for a moment, if had Rodgers stated his plan was to play for several more seasons.

  • The reaction would have been just as swift and probably far more harsh.

You can easily imagine the leads along the lines of, “…after three years of wandering in the wilderness following Ben Roethlisberger’s retirement, the franchise continues to refuse to pull off the band aid and embrace renewal.”

Ben Roethlisberger, Art Rooney II, Roethlisberger final game Heinz Field, Steelers vs Browns

Art Rooney II and Ben Roethlisberger embrace. Photo Credit: Steelers.com, Karl Roser

And that’s only how the immediate narrative would have gone before Rodgers has taken his first snap. You can imagine how it would have evolved once the Steelers begin hitting stumbling blocks.

4. A Potential Upside to It All

At the end of the day, this was a question Aaron Rodgers was going to get, and it says here he gave the right answer. Yes, it is certainly possible that, if things get tough, if say, Troy Fautanu fails to stay healthy and/or Broderick Jones doesn’t develop and Rodgers takes a pounding he’ll regret his decision.

  • But if we know anything about Aaron Rodgers, its that he’s a competitor.

So when he says this is probably his final year, he’s most likely signaling that he’s planning on leaving it all out on the field.

And that is something Steelers Nation should welcome.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

All the Right Words: Aaron Rodgers Says the Right Things @ Steelers Mini Camp

Aaron Rodgers made his debut in a Steelers uniform at mandatory minicamp. There’s one thing that’s already evident about the 4-time league MVP: He knows how to say the right things.

Shortly after Aaron Rodgers signed with the Steelers, yours truly wondered out loud if the 41 year old veteran “still loved football.” Retired Steelers scout Mark Gorsack had first posed the question on a podcast before the 2025 NFL Draft, but given that Rodgers signing seemed to be timed to miss OTAs, it was still worth asking.

Aaron Rodgers, Aaron Rodgers Pittsburgh Steelers

Aaron Rodgers 1st practice with the Steelers. Photo Credit: Karl Roser, Steelers.com

While no reporter asked Rodgers that directly, one did get pretty close inquiring, “Internally, though, is there a drive for you, motivation in terms of pursuing that?” Rodgers answer could have been clearer:

I have a lot that motivates me, but this is about the love of the game. The game has given me so much over the years. And making peace with a nice long career.

Even the most hardened Rodgers skeptic couldn’t have asked for a better answer. Of course “its very easy to say the words” as Art Rooney II once remarked about Ben Roethlisberger (albeit in a entirely different context.)

But here Rodgers is already matching words with deeds — when the highest paid player in NFL history signs a 13 million-and-change contract he’s clearly not doing it for the money.

But Rodgers right answers didn’t stop there. When pressed further about why he’s still playing, response was revealing:

I think that’s what it is. I don’t need it. For my ego, I don’t need it, to keep playing. A lot of decisions that I’ve made over my career and life from strictly the ego, even if they turn out well, they’re always unfulfilling. But the decisions made from the soul are usually pretty fulfilling.

Wow. An ancient Greek would interpret this as Rodgers saying he isn’t doing this just to fulfill the appetitive side of his soul, but also the spirited side. So yes, Aaron Rodgers still has passion for the game.

And there’s another element to consider: This is quite a statement from a player known for his me-first attitudes. The real test of course will come when Pat McAfee asks Rodgers if Calvin Austin, Roman Wilson or Pat Freiermuth ran the wrong route at a critical moment in a close loss.

But taken at face value, this is quite encouraging.

Aaron Rodgers didn’t practice with the team on the first day of mini camp. Instead the coaches had him listening to play calls through a helmet while reviewing play scripts. He did work in individual drills and connected with D.K. Metcalf several times.

The practice makes perfect curmudgeon in me still wants to say that he should practiced at minicamp just as he should have have been at OTAs, but Mike Tomlin seemed to be speaking to that when he argued that a guy like Will Howard benefited more from those snaps than Rodgers would have.

And Mike Tomlin would know better than me.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Question for Aaron Rodgers: Do You Still Love Football?

The moment that Steelers Nation had been dreading became real last week. Aaron Rodgers signed with the Pittsburgh Steelers.

He’ll meet the press after practice and it is this scribe’s hope that someone asks him the only remaining relevant question: “Do you still love football?”

  • Full disclosure: Credit for this idea goes to someone else.

Retired Steelers scout Mark Gorscak posed this question rhetorically on the Steel City Insider podcast right before 2025 NFL Draft. Since then, a lot’s been said about Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers.

Devin Bush, Aaron Rodgers, Steelers vs Packers

Devin Bush sacks Aaron Rodgers on 3rd down. Photo Credit: Karl Roser, Steelers.com

Very little has been done, save for the fact that Omar Khan and Mike Tomlin declined to reach for a quarterback in what is regarded as a historically weak quarterback class. (Quick aside: Gorscak also reminded listeners that “right now every NFL team is lying their asses off.” Self-styled draft experts who drank the Shedeur Sanders Kool Aid learned this the hard way.)

  • Now Gorsack’s question is the only that’s important.

Of course, age and/or injury could conspire to rob Rodgers of his remaining ability, but that’s both a known risk and also one that’s out of everyone’s control.

The answer to the question of whether Rodgers still loves the game, however carries critical importance. In the NFL true love for football carries equal importance as ability does.

Do you doubt that? Well, then just think back to the final drive of Super Bowl XLIII.

Yes, Ben Roethlisberger certainly needed Hall of Fame talent to execute one of the best game-winning drives in Super Bowl history. But passion powered his talent. To see for yourself go back and watch Roethlisberger’s reaction as he watches Kurt Warner’s hook up with Larry Fitzgerald.

Roethlisberger didn’t simply accept the fact that he had re-claim a lead his team had held for 57 minutes and 23 seconds of a Super Bowl — he embraced it because he thrived for those moments — and that’s founded on love for football.

The question of whether Aaron Rodgers can still muster that passion for the game is a legitimate one. He’s been a free agent since March. He’s clearly not doing it for the money. He could have put pen to paper at any moment. Yet, he waited until after OTAs had finished.

  • Does that mean that Aaron Rodgers no longer loves football?

When OTAs started and Rodgers was absent, Jeremy Hritz seemed to speak for much of Steelers Nation with this comment on the Steel City Insider message board:

Rogers future Hall of Famer absolutely but would rather have a teamer. You would think he’d be excited about the season and working with his new team. How could anyone be excited about his addition to the Steelers. Obviously his heart and desire is fading. Just an observation!

That’s the quick and easy conclusion to draw based on the fact that Rodgers conveniently timed his contract signing to miss the drudgery of OTAs. And, as an avowed Rodger’s skeptic, I fear that Hritz might be right.

  • But life has taught me that maybe Rodgers deserves the benefit of the doubt.

He’s said publicly and privately that someone close to him has been weathering some challenging times. And if that’s the case then maybe we should cut him a little slack. If you’re not sold on this, let me bring up the story of my friend of the late, great Steelers scribe Ivan Cole.

I had a chance to speak with Ivan shortly before he passed but failed to take advantage. No, I didn’t realize his condition was life-threatening, but that proves the point: People should take precedence over the proverbial “work to do and bills to pay.”

So let’s give Aaron Rodgers the benefit of that doubt on the timing of his contract signing.

But even as we extend him that benefit of the doubt, reporters should still ask him, “Do you still love football?”

Because his answer very well may determine the success or failure of his time in Pittsburgh.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Steelers Trade George Pickens to the Cowboys – Buyer and Seller Beware

The Pittsburgh Steelers are trading wide receiver George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys in a move screams “Both Buyer and Seller Beware.” The Steelers send George Pickens and a 2027 6th round pick to Dallas, and in exchange the Cowboys send their 2026 3rd rounder and 2027th 5th rounder to Pittsburgh.

Since even before the 2024 season ended, speculation abounded as to whether the Steelers would move on from George Pickens.

Coming out of the NFL combine Steel City Insider’s Jim Wexell reported Pickens had soured his trade value in the league, and that a trade would be “next to impossible.”

Yet, prior to the draft, George Pickens reportedly deleted references to the Steelers from his social media accounts, and Omar Khan did field calls about a potential trade but could not get more than a 4th round pick.

With the draft over, Jerry Jones has increased his offer for the ultra-talented, mercurial wide receiver and brought him to Texas.

George Pickens, Nick Cross, Steelers vs Colts

George Pickens fumbles at the 5 yard line. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune-Review

Steelers Exchange High Short-Term Risk for Long Term Value

George Pickens began tantalizing Steelers fans from the moment he stepped foot on Chuck Noll Field at St. Vincents College.

George Pickens, Steelers 2022 training camp, Cam Sutton

George Pickens making a catch on the first day @ St. Vincents. Photo Credit: Post-Gazette.com

In terms of pure pass-catching capability, Pickens is in the conversation with Lynn Swann and Antonio Brown.

  • Alas, Pickens mimicked Brown’s attitude issues. And then some.

For as unglued as Antonio Brown became in his final year in Pittsburgh, Brown’s self-centered disposition rarely, if ever, reared its head on the field.

  • The same cannot be said for George Pickens.

His immaturity was on display on the sidelines in the Steelers 2022 win over the Atlanta Falcons, prompting Cam Heyward to initiate a “heart-to-heart” on the sidelines. (Heyward, to his credit, said the young wide out simply needed a “Pick me up.”)

The antics continued through his second season, with Pickens declining to block for Jaylen Warren near the goal line, citing injury concerns. This is only the tip of the iceberg.

George Pickens, Noah Igbinoghene, Steelers vs Dolphins

George Pickens with another Lynn Swann like catch. Photo Credit: Yahoo! Sports

Pickens proved, time-and-time again, he could make belief defying catches.

Yet it was almost like he was bent on establishing a 1-1 relationship between those feats and team-destructive incidents, whether it was cutting off routes, showing up late, taking plays off, using his face paint to complain about lack of targets, getting into shoving matches with defensive backs in Hail Mary situations, or needing to be restrained from fighting with fans by Pat Freiermuth.

As he did with Kenny Pickett, Justin Fields and Russell Wilson, Omar Khan began the off season singing Pickett’s praises and talking about his plans to keep in in Pittsburgh.

  • Now Pickens is headed to Dallas.

In football realpolitik the Steelers got a steal. They weren’t going to resign him, they may not have gotten a good compensatory pick for him, and unhappiness over lack of a new contract could have been a season-long disruption.

If the Steelers get four compensatory picks for the 2026 NFL Draft, they’ll have 12 picks at their disposal.

But by playing the long game, Omar Khan has once again exposed the team to short-term risk.

Another Year of Longing for Lockett and Hill?

Last season the Steelers dealt problem child wide receiver Diontae Johnson. It was a wise move. Donte Jackson delivered solid play at cornerback while Johnson got himself cut three times.  However, Omar Khan never filled the gaping hole that Johnson’s departure left on the roster.

Dwight Stone, Dwight Stone Steelers career

Dwight Stone’s Steelers career ran from 1987 to 1994. Photo Credit: Amazon

Early in the season, this scribe opined that the lack of a number two wide out opposite Pickens was enough to make Gen X Steelers fans long for the days of Charles Lockett, Derek Hill and Dwight Stone.

The Steelers of course added D.K. Metcalf in the off season, and Calvin Austin improved noticeably last year, but outside of that they’ve got a wide receiver room filled with roster bubble players or unproven youth, such as Roman Wilson, with Robert Woods taking Van Jefferson’s place.

When the Steelers drafted Kaleb Johnson word was he excelled in running against stacked boxes at Iowa.

Good thing he’s already used to playing in Black and Gold, because he’s going to see plenty of other familiar sights in Pittsburgh. Seller be wear.

Now Jones and Schottenhimer to Try Their Hand

Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin stood behind George Pickens for as long as he could. He opted not to air his dirty laundry and instead focus trying to break through to Pickens.

  • At times it appeared to work.

After an awful game against the Colts in December 2023, no one would have criticized Tomlin if he just decided to bench Pickens for the rest of the year. Instead, Tomlin talked to him and Pickens exploded for two break out games on Christmas and New Years. He even showed up as a blocker in the season finale against the Ravens.

Yet, after two senseless personal foul penalties in the road win over the Bengals last year, Tomlin said it was time for Pickens to grow up.

  • Clearly, he feels he’s mentored Pickens as far as he can.

Now Brian Schottenheimer and Jerry Jones will launch a wide receiver reclamation project. Other head coaches have tried and failed with similar endavors with Steelerss cast offs such as Brown, Johnson, Martavis Bryant and Chase Claypool.

Buyer beware.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Pittsburgh Steelers 2025 Undrafted Rookie Free Agent Class

After the New England Patriots officially made defensive back Kobee Minor out of Memphis as Mr. Irrelevant, Omar Khan’s team pivoted from the Steelers 2025 Draft Class to getting the Steelers 2025 Undrafted Rookie Free Agent class under contract.

D.J. Thomas-Jones, Fullback, South Alabama
Roc Taylor, Wide Receiver, Memphis
Ke’Shawn Williams, Wide Receiver, Indiana
J.J. Galbreath, Tight End, South Dakota
Aiden Williams, Guard, Minnesota-Duluth
Sebastian Castro, Defensive Back, Iowa
Ben Sauls, Kicker, Pittsburgh

While these men are the “Rudys” of the NFL, each of these new faces should take heart that the Steelers have a rich tradition with undrafted rookie free agents.

Donnie Shell, Joe Montana, Steelers vs 49ers

Hall of Famer vs Hall of Famer: Donnie Shell stares down Joe Montana. Photo Credit: George Gojkovich, Getty Images via SI.com

Donnie Shell was an Undrafted Rookie Free Agent who joined after the 1974 draft class was set, and he’s now in the Hall of Fame.

As Shell was finishing his final season in Pittsburgh, Dwight Stone joined the Steelers part of their 1987 Undrafted Rookie Free Agent class. Stone parlayed that opportunity into a 17-year NFL career with the Steelers and Jets that saw him play in 171 games making 154 starts. Ramon Foster followed a similar route, playing 11 years and making 145 including on in Super Bowl XLV.

In Super Bowl XL Willie Parker set the NFL record for longest run from scrimmage and in Super Bowl XLIII James Harrison set the record for the longest interception return in the game’s history, and both men joined the Steelers as Undrafted Rookie Free Agents.

More recently, Jaylen Warren arrived in Pittsburgh as part of the Steelers 2021 Undrafted Rookie Free Agent class and will enter training camp as the starting running back.

Of the group above, logistically speaking, D.J. Thomas-Jones has the best chance to make the team. For starters, the Steelers paid him a $30,000 dollar signing bonus, the highest in team history per Steel City Insider’s Roy Countryman.

Arthur Smith believes in the fullback, and the Steelers were ready to offer real money to Kyle Juszczk. So Thomas-Jones has a slot “greyed out” for him that he can secure by showing he can play fullback and contribute on special teams.

Sebastian Castro is another player with potential, who in the eyes of Countryman, suffered from a bad combine but built a solid tape for the Iowa Hawkeyes.

Ben Sauls doesn’t have much of a chance of replacing Chris Boswell, but Acrisure Stadium is one of the toughest places to kick, and he showed at Pitt he’s up to that challenge.

And like everyone else, he’ll get a fair shake at St. Vincents.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Steelers 2025 Draft Class – Khan and Tomlin Play the Long Game

It took 7 picks, 3 days 2 trades but the Pittsburgh Steelers 2025 Draft Class is now complete.

For the record, the Steelers made 5 defensive picks and two offensive picks, but reading between the lines, it is more likely the case that they made 3 defensive picks, 2 offensive picks, and two special teams picks.

Pittsburgh Steelers 2025 Draft Class

Via Steelers.com

As always, Steel Curtain Rising will ignore the rush to affix a grade to the Steelers 2025 Draft Class, although we’ve already learned something important:

  • Omar Khan and Mike Tomlin are playing the long game.

We’ll get into that in a moment, but first, let’s take a look at the newest members of the Pittsburgh Steelers

First Round: Derrick Harmon, Defensive Tackle, Oregon
Third Round: Kaleb Johnson, Running Back, Iowa
Fourth Round: Jack Sawyer, Outside Linebacker, Ohio State
Fifth Round: Yaha Black, Defensive Tackle, Iowa
Sixth Round: Will Howard, Quarterback, Ohio State
Seventh Round: Carson Bruener, Inside Linebacker, Washington
Seventh Round: Donte Kent, Cornerback/Punt Returner, Central Michigan

As Omar Khan and Mike Tomlin have been quick to point out, although he’s not a member of the Steelers 2025 Draft Class strictly speaking, D.K. Metcalf came to Pittsburgh by way of their 2nd round pick. And he certainly figures to make an immediate impact.

What the Steelers 2025 Draft Class Already Teaches Us

Same day draft grades are about as relevant as opening day batting averages. It will take years before we really how much value, or lack thereof this draft will deliver to the Steelers. (Case in point the Steelers 2016 and 1989 Draft classes both looked very good in January 2017 and 1989, but after that, not so much).

But there are a few lessons we can already take aways:

1. Khan and Tomlin Tune Out the Noise

Having been spurned by Justin Fields and having spurned Russell Wilson while waiting on Aaron Rodgers, quarterback was the Steelers biggest need heading into the draft.

But, reports to the contrary from both the national and local press, it is clear that the Steelers never considered addressing it in the first round.

Nor were they in a hurry to do so afterwards. Armed with a potential 4 compensatory picks in the 2026 NFL Draft, Khan could have dealt away a couple-of-three 4th, 3rd and 2nd round picks from next year to move up into the second round or earlier in the third round to get a quarterback. Not only did he not do that, but the Steelers waited until the 6th round to get their signal caller.

You don’t wait to draft a quarterback until the 6th round if you plan on playing him in the coming season. Both Mike Tomlin and Art Rooney II indicated they still expect Aaron Rodgers to sign, but the Steelers are perfectly content to address their long-term need at quarterback in 2026.

Meanwhile, they focused on adding value while preserving draft capital – the only trade the Khan artist made was to move back in the 5th get an extra 7th.

2. The Ridiculing from the Ravens Still Stings

While the Steelers are playing the long game, that doesn’t mean they’re being short-sighted. They drafted three players whose pedigree as run defenders is strong. Derrick Henry reduced the Steelers defense to road kill, and the Steelers brain trust has not reacted that sitting down.

This goes hand-in-hand with playing the long game.

With T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Nick Herbig, outside linebacker was anything but a Steelers draft need in 2025. Yet Kahn and Tomlin scooped up Jack Sawyer, an outside linebacker from Ohio State.

Sawyer’s specialty? Stopping the run. And if you’re questioning whether he can do that from so far down in the depth chart, keep in mind that Preston Smith played in 30% of the Steelers defensive snaps last season.

Its doubtful that the rookie will match that, but it does show that OLB No. 4 does have a role in this defense.

3. Art Rooney Sr.’s Wisdom Remains as Valid as Ever

After the 2008 NFL Draft, Gene Coillier wrote a piece grading the Steelers 2003 Draft class, harking back to Chuck Noll’s credo that it took 5 years to grade a draft. In it he quoted Art Rooney Sr., who’d told him, “Everyone’s a winner on draft day.”

  • The Steelers were wise to beef up their run defense in this draft.
  • Harmon, Sawyer and Black should strengthen the front seven
  • Collectively, making an immediate difference is plausible

But as Steelers rival Bum Philips would remind us, “It ain’t bragging if you can do it, but just saying it don’t make it so.” You can address all of the potential problems you want to in the draft, but the players must deliver on the field.

Think back to where the Steelers were ten years ago. Turnovers had been in short supply in the Steelers 2014 season and really, since Super Bowl XLV. So the Steelers 2015 Draft Class saw them add Senquez Golson, Doran Grant and Gerod Holliman. The trio brought a collective total of 39 collegiate interceptions to Pittsburgh, with 29 of those coming in their final year in college.

  • Those college numbers impress.
  • These professional numbers depress: 3, 1 and 17

That’s 3 NFL games, 1 defensive snap and 17 special teams snaps, which make up the trios’ combined NFL stat line. All of these came from Doran Grant, as Holliman got cut in camp, while Senquez Golson saw his NFL career destroyed by injuries before it ever started.

The story of the Steelers 2015 draft class isn’t intended as buzz kill, but rather as a reminder that the watch word coming out of the draft should be patience.

Hopes are high now – as they should be – but more often than not, it takes time to realize those. Troy Polamalu looked lost his rookie year, by 2004 he was flashing Hall of Fame potential. Going into his third season, more than a few fans were ready to hang the “B” word around Cam Heyward’s neck; well, we know how that turned out.

The point is, if by the time the leaves are changing color and Halloween decorations are going up and Derrick Harmon isn’t dominating or Kaleb Johnson isn’t looking his name should be Franco Bettis, don’t panic.

4. Everyone IS a winner on draft day, and that’s good.

Art Rooney Sr. was right – everyone IS a winner on draft day, and that’s a good thing. The NFL draft is about hope. Hope for franchises. Hope for the scouts and coaches. Hope for the fans.

  • And most importantly, hope for the players.

Last week Omar Khan and Mike Tomlin made a dream come true for 7 young men, giving them something they’ve aspired to since they first put their hands on a Nerf football and barked out a bogus snap count as kids.

The moment is theirs – for Derrick Harmon it certainly is bittersweet – but as a draft class I hope they enjoy it.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Steelers Draft Conte Kent “Swiss Army Knife” in 7th Round of 2025 Draft

The Pittsburgh Steelers closed the 2025 NFL Draft by picking Central Michigan’s cornerback/punt returner Donte Kent with their second 7th round selection and the 229th pick overall.

Donte Kent, Steelers 7th round pick Donte Kent

Pittsburgh Steelers 7th round pick Donte Kent. Photo Credit: Yahoo! Sports

The speculation is that the Steelers will use Donte Kent mostly on special teams, but Mike Tomlin described him this way:

He has a Swiss Army Knife skill set. He’s capable of playing inside and out. He also added to his resume this year by proving to be a very capable punt returner, and I think that’s things that are attractive to you later in the draft, a guy that adds versatility in his game. So we’re excited about putting him in the mix.

Mike Tomlin his historically shied away from using defensive backs to return kicks, preferring to delegate those duties to running backs such as Mewelde Moore, Stefan Logan or wide receivers such as Antonio Brown, Diontae Johnson or Calvin Austin.

But Kent should at least get a shot at auditioning for the job during preseason. With that said, the last late round defensive back that Tomlin described as a “Swiss Army Knife” was Tre Norwood, whom the Steelers also drafted in the 7th round of the 2021 NFL Draft. Norwood saw action in 32 games during the 2021 and 2022 season, before getting cut in 2023.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.