Taken from the grade book of a teacher wanting to whine after seeing visitors drinking wine at Acrisure, here is the Pittsburgh Steelers Report Card for the loss to the Cowboys in Sunday Night Football.
Quarterback
Justin Fields passing numbers were solid, completing 15 of 27 for 2 touchdowns and no interceptions. He also ran 6 times for 27 sometimes tough yards. Nonetheless, Fields missed makeable throws that could have been difference-makers for a struggling offense. To wit, the Steelers were 3-12 on third downs. Grade: C
Running Backs
Najee Harris actually led the team in receptions, catching two passes for 35 yards. That’s good, but Najee Harris is a running back. And for the second straight week he did not run well. He may have come out slightly better in the ‘eye test’ but his numbers 42 yards on 14 carries don’t lie. Aaron Shampklin and Jonathan Ward looked good in spot duty but not enough to provide a spark. Grade: F
Tight Ends
The tight ends provided both touchdown catches on the night, with Pat Freiermuth catching 3 balls for 22 yards and Connor Heyward catching 2 for 23. Darnell Washington also had 1 catch for 5 yards. Grade: B
Wide Receivers
The good news? Van Jefferson shed his invisibility cloak for this game. The bad news? His 3 catches for 26 yards look more like mop up numbers that WR No 2 stats. WR No. 1 George Pickens also had 3 catches for 26 yards…. Calvin Austin had 1 catch for 6 yards and Brandon Johnson (who?) had 1 catch for 9 yards.
Stats like these make graying Generation X Steelers fan long for the days of Weegie Thompson and Dwight Stone. Ouch! Grade: F
Offensive Line
Isaac Seumalo returned to the offensive line and added a veteran presence. It may take him time to find his feet, as Justin Fields took 8 hits and suffered 3 sacks, and the Steelers consistently lost on 1st and 2nd down setting up third and longs. All of that might not be on the line, but some of it certainly is. Grade: D
Defensive Line
Look at the box score and you’ll see that the Dallas Cowboys rushing attack probably lacked the “wow” factor. But whatever they lacked there, they made up for consistency. The Cowboys establish the run early on and leaned into it on their final drive. All of this doesn’t fall on the shoulders of the defensive line. But it starts there. Grade: D
Linebackers
T.J. Watt got his 100th sack on a play here he and Nick Herbig brought Dak Prescott down, stripping the ball in the Red Zone. Watt later helped wreck a drive in the 3rd quarter with a sack. Payton Wilson had nine tackles and was around the ball. Patrick Queen led the unit in tackles with 9 while Elandon Roberts forced a fumble that should have been a game changer. Those are all positives, but the linebackers failed to bring pressure on Prescott when it counted and they too deserve their share of the blame for Dallas’ success on the ground. Grade: C-
Secondary
Joey Porter Jr. hauled what should have been a game-shifting interception, and Donte Jackson had a pick in the end zone that took at least 3 points off the board. Minkah Fitzpatrick made several key stops. But Dallas converted 9 of 15 third down attempts and made it look all too easy in the process. DeShon Elliott manned up after the game – but he was hardly the only one at fault. Grade: D
Special Teams
Chris Boswell kicked a 41 yarder. Corliss Waitman’s punting was solid and, unfortunately, could probably gain a few votes for offensive MVP. Dallas forced the Steelers to return kicks and Aaron Shampklin did a respectable job. Isaiahh Loudermilk blocked a field goal. Grade: B+
Coaching
Where to start?
Arthur Smith’s offense doesn’t come with a lot of frills. His philosophy is focused establishing the run by dominating at the line of scrimmage, setting up play action passing to create chunk plays.
This formula worked slowly, but reasonably well through the first three weeks of the season. But things have gone downhill fast. For the second straight week the Steelers have failed to establish the run, and effectively asked Justin Fields to win the game for them, when he clearly lacks the receivers to do that.
Smith likes to line his quarterbacks up under center, but Justin Fields worked extensively in the shotgun on both touchdown drives. While those touchdowns were nice, over reliance on the shotgun could complicate things.
Shotgun or no, Dallas came to Pittsburgh with a terrible rushing defense and missing its best two defenders, yet they clearly got the better of the Steelers rushing attack.
- Teryl Austin has a different problem.
He’s got a defense that is capable of making splash plays that should be game-changing. Yet they keep getting beaten on bread-and-butter downs. As the Elandon Roberts play proved, forcing a fumble at the one doesn’t mean a whole lot if you can’t stop a four yard pass on 4th and 4.
To be fair to Austin, by the end of the game, the Steelers had lost Nick Herbig and DeMarvin Leal, making 5th string outside linebacker Jeremiah Moon the next man up. Any defense in the NFL is going to struggle a bit in those circumstances.
But that neither explains nor confuses the lackluster play on the defensive line or the miscommunications and/or ineffectiveness of the inside linebackers.

Cam Heyward was one of the few rights spots for the Steelers. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune-Review
Mike Tomlin has said that an NFL team definition its identity during the first six weeks of the season. During weeks 1-3 the Steeler that definition looked pretty sharp. Focus slipped a little in week four but still looked good.
But in week 5 the Pittsburgh stuck “smashing grapes.” And it wasn’t pretty. Grade: F
Unsung Hero Award
Five weeks ago he was being mocked as a player getting a “scholarship year.” Since then he’s been the best player in his unit, by far, and against the Cowboys he was the only defensive lineman to turn in a truly good performance. And for that Cam Heyward wins the Unsung Hero Award for the Steelers 2024 loss to the Cowboys at Acrisure.


















