Three Pittsburgh Steelers quarterbacks have thrown for at least five touchdowns in a game. Terry Bradshaw is obviously one of them. Ben Roethlisberger is another (Big Ben in fact has done it four times). But who was the third?
Surely someone like the legendary Bobby Layne, right? And if it wasn’t him, certainly it was Neil O’Donnell, Kordell Stewart or maybe even a gunslinger like Tommy Maddox, right? Nope.
Try Mark Malone.
- Yes, you read correctly, Mark Malone once threw 5 touchdown passes in game.
Mark Malone, who played for the Steelers for eight years in the 1980s and was the team’s primary starting quarterback from mid-way through the ’84 campaign until the Steelers traded Malone to the Chargers (for an 8th round pick) following the ’87 season, was never a fan-favorite based the fact that he had to replace a future Hall of Famer and, obviously, his poor career stats.
Malone Not Alone in Succeeding the Blond Bomber…
Malone was the Steelers first round pick in the 1980 NFL Draft, just months after they won Super Bowl XIV, their 4th championship in six years behind the legendary Terry Bradshaw. Was Malone, a magnificent athlete who passed for 3,388 yards and rushed for another 1,344 during his three years at Arizona State, going to be groomed as the heir apparent to the Blond Bomber?
- It didn’t necessarily seem so at the time.
As Malone explained to New York Times in January of 1985 as he prepared to face Miami in the 1984 AFC Championship game, how could he ever replace Bradshaw, who was just 31 years old when the youngster was drafted?
When I was drafted by the Steelers, friends back home in San Diego asked, ‘How will you ever get a chance to play with Bradshaw there?
But, again, Malone was so physically gifted that when Lynn Swann was injured heading into a Week 10 match-up in Seattle during the ’81 season, Steelers head coach Chuck Noll asked him to play wide-receiver. While Malone only caught one pass, it went for a 90-yard touchdown (a franchise record that stood for years).
- Unfortunately for Malone, he injured his knee in the game against the Seahawks that would require surgery in the offseason and force him to miss all of 1982.
Even after Bradshaw retired following the 1983 season and Cliff Stoudt departed for the USFL, the Steelers acquired David Woodley from the Dolphins prior to the 1984 campaign, and he ultimately beat-out Malone for the starting job.
But, David Woodley wasn’t up to the job, and Malone became the permanent starter in the second half of the season, as he led the ’84 Steelers to five victories, a 9-7 record and Chuck Noll’s last AFC Central Division title.
Among those victories was an upset over the eventual Super Bowl champion 49ers in Week 7 (San Francisco’s only loss in ’84 and the 1st of two Noll/Malone wins over Walsh/Montana) and a 52-24 thrashing of the Chargers in Week 13 at old Three Rivers Stadium; in the blow-out win, Malone passed for 253 yards and four touchdowns and, according to his Wikipedia page, became the first quarterback in team history to complete over 80 percent of his passes in a game (18 of 22).
- Other notable performances during the ’84 campaign occurred in the postseason.
Mark Malone helped the Steelers become the first road team to win a playoff game in Denver, after a 24-17 victory over the Broncos in the divisional round. One week later, he threw for 312 yards, three touchdowns and three interceptions, as Pittsburgh fell to the Dolphins, 45-28, in the AFC Championship game in Miami’s Orange Bowl.
1985 Steelers Appeared Poised for Greatness
While Mark Malone didn’t make anyone forget about Terry Bradshaw during the second half of the ’84 season, he certainly did enough to earn the starting nod moving forward, providing the perfect backdrop for Mark Malone’s shining moment.
- To understand this, you’ve got to understand the context in which the Steelers started the 1985 season.
The 85 Steelers were a new team with a mostly revamped roster that included an exciting, young receiver named Louis Lipps, 1984’s NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year. And this retooled roster had renewed Pittsburgh’s enthusiasm with three-straight playoff-appearances and provided objective evidence that the Steel Curtain was poised to rise again.
- Pittsburgh opened the ’85 campaign at home against the Colts on September 8.
Malone, coming off several impressive performances the year before, had the game of his life in-front of a sell-out crowd, completing 21 of 30 passes for 287 yards and five touchdowns, as he tied Bradshaw’s single-game record just one year after he retired.
To add to Malone’s career-day, he also scored on a one-yard touchdown run giving him a hand in 6 touchdowns in a 45-3 blow-out victory.
- According to the young quarterback, whom the Colts defenders failed to sack all day, it was a total team effort.
As Malone clarified to the UPI after the game:
I thought I had a good game. But as I’ve said in the past–and I think it’s extremely important–when two receivers run good routes and those guys in front are giving you time and you’re running the ball, well, you’re going to have good days.
Those two receivers Malone was referring to were Lipps, who caught nine passes for 154 yards and three touchdowns, and the legendary John Stallworth, who also tallied a score. Chuck Noll’s Steelers had struggled in the early 80’s, but Malone’s 5 touchdown game on opening day vs. the Colts, Pittsburgh appeared poised to dominate the second half of the decade.
- Unfortunately, the Steelers finished 7-9 and suffered their first losing season since 1971; as for Malone, he only played in 10 games in ’85 due to an injury.
Malone started a combined 26 games over the next two seasons, but the playoff-less trend continued, as Pittsburgh failed to quality in 1986 and again in 1987. Whatever scorn the fans initially felt for the embattled quarterback intensified during these years, as he threw just 21 touchdown passes to a whopping 37 interceptions.
Those fans, and many reporters, who hardly criticized Mark Malone during his time in Pittsburgh certainly had Just Cause. In eight seasons with the Steelers, Malone had 60 touchdown passes to 81 interceptions and a passer-rating of 50.2.
- In fact, in his final season as a starter, Malone had 46.4 passer rating (yes, that forty six point four)
Malone, who has had long-lasting success as a sportscaster and sports personality after retiring, never had a career even approaching that of a decent NFL quarterback.
But on opening day of the 1985 regular season Mark Malone authored in one of the most underrated quarterback performances in Pittsburgh Steelers history. For that he should be proud.
2 thoughts on “Steelers Throwback Thursday: Mark Malone’s 5 Touchdown Game vs. the Colts in 1985”
Malone wasn’t that bad. He was 12-14 as a starter his last two years playing almost exclusively without Lipps (who missed more than half of 86 and all but 1 game in 87 with injuries) & only half that time with Stallworth, who in his final season was a shell of his former greatness. Malone was working largely with a WR corps of Calvin Sweeney, Weegie Thompson, Charles Lockett, with no TE or RB who could catch. He wasn’t great by any means but it would have been hard to put up prolific stats with that crew.
Malone did lead the NFL in avg yards per completion in 1984 & rank 6th in avg yards per pass (with a healthy Lipps & Stallworth in the line up and pass catching Rich Erinberg coming out of the backfield). In addition to his prolific games vs SD in 84 & IND in 85 he passed for 374 yards & 3TD vs Cin on Monday Night Football in 85, played two very good games against 12 win Conf Title Game bound CLE in 86, had a 3TD, 190 yard performance in a road win vs GB, outplayed Dan Fouts again in a late season 87 road win to keep Pgh in playoff contention, and beat Cin in 87 with a 42 yard TD run in a mid season road win.
Even after he left he passed for nearly 300 yards and scored 28 pts in shoot-out with Dan Marino and Mia in his 1st SD start, tallied a 36 yard TD run vs SF, and beat Pgh with a 17 of 24, 2 TD (1 passing, 1 rushing) performance late in the 88 season.
Given the team’s lack of depth (and health) at WR his last two years and the shoddy play of a suspect secondary (D. Woodruff & an ageing Donnie Shell surrounded by a revolving door of short lived busts like Harvey Clayton) & mediocre D-line on a defense that under achieved and was usually propped up by its linebackers corps (seemingly it’s only strength) it’s a wonder Malone & Pgh stayed in playoff contention till the end of the 87 season and managed a 5-3 close to the 86 campaign after a slow start.
Malone wasn’t the problem….he just wasn’t the answer
Thanks for commenting Tom.
I like your conclusion “Malone wasn’t the problem… he just wasn’t the answer.” So true.