6 Quick Takeaways as Steelers Lose 17-14 to Buccaneers in Preseason

The Pittsburgh Steelers dropped their preseason home opener to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to the tune of 17-14, as a late Logan Woodside interception gave Tampa Bay the ball deep in Steelers territory, allowing them to kick a field goal as time expired.

The result itself tells us very little. The game yielded both good and bad takeaways for Steelers fans, and here are 6 of those plus a bonus program note.

Keeanu Benton, Steelers vs Buccaneers 2025 preseason

Keeanu Benton blocks a pass. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune-Review

1. Absence of Starters Self-Evident

Mike Tomlin opted to sit at least 20 players going into the game, including 13 who could be considered starters, including his top three skill players, Aaron Rodgers, D.K. Metcalf and Jaylen Warren.

ON the defensive side, T.J. Watt, DeShon Elliott, Jalen Ramsey, Darius Slay and Joey Porter also sat.

We’ll only know if that’s a wise football decision if the Steelers can avoid sloppy play in early September, and succeed in dodging the injury bug by late December. But from a product marketing perspective, the product on the field clearly suffered.

Chuck Noll, Bill Cowher

Chuck Noll & Bill Cower after the last game at Three Rivers Stadium. Photo via 6th Ring.com

Not that the men who suited up were delivering sub-standard performances, but this game had the look and feel of a preseason contest – far cry from August of 1994 when a preseason contest between the Steelers and Raiders got so heated that Rod Woodson found himself ejected.

After the game the intensity had Bill Cowher telling Chuck Noll, “I don’t know what you started, but it seems like I’ve got to finish it.” (Or something close to that, this quote’s from memory.)

2. The Kids Are Alright

Collectively, the Steelers looked good in their preseason win over the Jaguars last week. But rookie running back Kaleb Johnson looked lost at times, and Derrick Harmon remained invisible on the stat sheet.

That had some commentators worried, but the take away here was “The Kids Will be Alright.”

  • And against the Buccaneers, they were.

Derrick Harmon drew several double-teams and overall appeared disruptive, and managed a sack Kyle Trask with a pure bull rush. Kaleb Johnson average 4.5 yards a carry on 11 runs including a long one of 14 yards. He also had a catch of 9 yards.

Moreover, Johnson looked sharp as a kick returner, averaging 27 yards a return with a long one of 34.

3. When in Rome, Do As the Romans?

Several members of the Steelers 2024 draft class had their rookie years ruined by injuries. Out of that group, perhaps no one was a bigger X factor than Roman Wilson. When asked about his wide receiver room following the George Pickens trade, Omar Khan expressed confidence in his 2025 group and rejected comparisons to the team’s situation at the same point in 2024.

  • He didn’t mention Roman Wilson by name, but he didn’t have to.

After a shaky start at St. Vincents, Wilson’s name became mentioned more prominently. He played well against the Jaguars, and made two impressive catches against the Buccaneers that totaled 72 yards.

  • Clearly, Roman Wilson is headed in the right direction.

But has he shown enough to make Mike Tomlin and Omar Khan going with Metcalf, Calvin Austin and Wilson as their top 3 wide outs. Even if Scott Miller and Brandon Johnson have looked good in preseason, the Steelers depth at wide out remains thin.

4. Run Blocking A Concern?

The good news is that, for the second straight week, Broderick Jones and Troy Fautanu looked good in pass protection.

However, overall the Steelers run blocking, which has been a weakness in training camp, looked so-so at best against the Buccaneers. Yes, Lew Nichols and Evan Hull had long runs, but Kenneth Gainwell “started” and got nowhere in his two runs against Tampa’s number 1s.

Historically, preseason has been a pretty good barometer for performance of specific units. Indeed, in the summer of 1998 it seemed that the Steelers run blocking was slipping. When the regular season started, the unit did OK, particularly when Alan Faneca worked himself into the lineup, but things went south after injuries ended Justin Strzelczyk’s season and career.

5. Punt It Out

One of the few true position battles the Steelers have this summer is at punter. Both Corliss Waitman and Cameron Johnston leaned into the completion Saturday night.

Waitman averaged 58 yards on his punts, and although Johnston “only” average 42 yards, in did get two inside the 20. Danny Smith and Mike Tomlin don’t have an easy decision in front of them, but that’s a good problem to have.

6. Odds and Sods

Cole Holcomb had another outstanding night and appears to be back inform following his gruesome injury suffered in the middle of 2023. Keeanu Benton also deflected a pass and rebounded from a subpar game last week.

If all goes well, the Steelers won’t see Miles Killebrew lining up in the secondary this fall, but he also had a pass defensed. So did Beanie Bishop and Brandin Echols.

The Steelers depth at inside linebacker and in the secondary appears to be solid.

Bonus: Program Note on DAZN

For the second straight week I watched that ad-free replay of the game on DAZN, which owns NFL Game Pass international. And for the second straight week, edits not only eliminated commercials, but also key series.

Last week it was Max Hurlman’s catch and touchdown. This week it was Ben Sauls missed field goal.

I do realize that DAZN is headquartered in London, England and therefore some of their production team might not be well-versed in American football, but get it together guys.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

6 Late & (Not So) Random Hits on Steelers Preseason Win Over Jags

The Pittsburgh Steelers opened the 2025 preseason with a 31-25 win over the Jacksonville Jaguars on Saturday night. Family time keep me from watching the game until Sunday night and work to do and bills to pay prevented me from publishing this until today.

With that, here were 6 (not necessarily) random takeaways from the game.

Kaleb Johnson, Steelers vs Jaguars preseason 2025

Kaleb Johnson rushes in his preseason debut. Photo Credit: AP via Tribune-Review

1. Still Sweating the Offense?

It was what, a little more than a week ago the word out of St. Vincents was that the defense as dominant but that the offense was, generously put, sluggish.

Well, that sluggish offense just put up 31 points on a humid Florida night. What’s more, Mason Rudolph looked almost flawless, and Skyler Thompson even has some calling for Will Howard to do a red shirt year on IR.

  • Take all of that with a grain of salt.

The glow of those preseason stat sheets can transform into a ugly, smudgy glare once the games count for real. Kenny Pickett and Matt Canada can attest. Still it was good to see.

More importantly, it was the way that they got those 31 points that impressed.

2. Air Arthur?

Don’t look now, but Steelers quarterbacks threw 38 passes – and they did so voluntarily and effectively. The good news is that Steelers offensive tackles Troy Fautanu and Broderick Jones looked good and kept their quarterbacks clean.

It is easy to see why. The Steelers want to see what they have in Roman Wilson, and know that they need him to prove himself to be starter capable this season. He looked good on Sunday night. So did Scotty Miller.

Perhaps more importantly, Smith’s quarterbacks exploited the middle of the field – something at Russell Wilson was loath to do last year, and frankly it was an area that Steelers offense avoided brief lifetime of the Kenny Pickett era.

3. Pierre Proving You Can Come Home Again?

During the preseason-less COVID summer of 2020, Steel City Insider wrote about an undrafted rookie free agent cornerback named James Pierre. Pierre made the final roster, got some playing time and was working his way in as a starter in 2021.

He hit some rough patches and didn’t play as much in 2022 or 2023. The Steelers let him walk as a free agent but brought him back when Washington cut him.

James Pierre, Steelers vs. Browns

James Pierre intercepts Jameis Winston. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune-Review

Pierre was mainly brought back for special teams, and resigned for the same reason. But he’s had as strong camp and played extremely aggressively Sunday night. He may get caught up in the numbers game, but it won’t be an easy decision.

4. Flying to the Ball

Teryl Austin’s defense flew to the ball Sunday night. And if DeMarvin Leal and Jack Sawyer didn’t generate much pass rush, It didn’t look like there were any missed tackles.

Sebastian Castro, Juan Thornhill, Chuck Clark, Beanie Bishop and Brain Echols all looked sharp and likely to make Grady Brown and Austin burn the midnight oil as they finalize cuts in the secondary.

Payton Wilson and Cole Holcomb also had good nights as inside linebacker could be another “problematic” area on the depth chart to winnow down.

5. The Kids Will Be Alright

Thus far the reports on rookies Derrick Harmon, Kaleb Johnson and Jack Sawyer have been nothing but positive. The same can be said for Yahya Black and Will Howard (who was hurt.)

Yet, the rookie who shown brightest was none other than Carson Bruener, who played well both on special teams and defense.

In contrast, Harmon, Johnson and Sawyer looked like, well rookies getting their feet wet in their first preseason game.

  • Is that a reason to worry? Absolutely not.

IF James Harrison had flashed the potential the type of player who’d make 4 scores of sacks, he’d wouldn’t have been cut 4 times. Yes, Ryan Shazier authored a strong preseason debut. And Franco Harris’ was sensational.

But there are two other names to keep in context: Jarvis Jones and Huey Richardson.

Jones recovered a fumble and had ESPN calling him Harrison’s heir apparent. You can read more about Richardson’s debut here, but he had a sack, two pressures and a forced fumble while playing inside linebacker and defensive tackle en route to becoming the worst first round bust in Steelers history.

In short, there’s either worrisome or wrong with rookie looking like rookies in their preseason debut.

6. NFL’s Been De-emphasizing Preseason, Tomlin Leans In

When he arrived in Pittsburgh, Mike Tomlin didn’t shy from playing his starters, although he wisely paced them. But with the arrival of the 17 game season, Mike Tomlin has played his starters less and less. T.J. Watt, Cam Heyward, Patrick Queen, Aaron Rodgers and D.K. Metcalf among others did not suit up.

That however provided opportunities for young guys to get a shot at their NFL dream.

And as we saw, the men took their opportunity to heart. Good for them.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

4 (Not So) Random Reflections on Aaron Rodgers’ & The R Word

In case you’ve been hiding under a rock, last week Aaron Rodgers went on the Pat McAfee show and told everyone what they already knew – that the 2025 season with the Steelers will likely be his last.

  • And of course that’s all anyone in Steelers Nation was talking about.

Here are four (not so) random reflections on Aaron Rodgers and the R word

Aaron Rodgers, Aaron Rodgers Pittsburgh Steelers

Aaron Rodgers 1st practice with the Steelers. Photo Credit: Karl Roser, Steelers.com

1. And This is Supposed to News?

So how is it that a 20 year NFL veteran and 41 year old quarterback saying that the coming season will likely be his last qualifies as “news.”

HAD Rodger had said he wanted to play “a couple-of-three or so more seasons,” THAT would have been news. Instead, he told us what we knew, and we ended up talking about it for week.

  • There’s no secret as to why.

The NFL’s media ecosystem has a voracious need for page visits, clicks and podcast/video views that demands to be fed. Hence, a 41 year old quarterback saying he’ll probably retire after 17 weeks of getting hit by 300 pound plus 20 something is now “news.”

2. The Story Line Is Set

Credit former Steelers offensive lineman Trai Essex for saying the quiet part out loud:

One way or another, the story line is set.

If Rodgers struggles out of the gate, it will be, “…its pretty obvious that Rodgers should have listened to his inner voice and gotten on with his ‘Life’s Work.’”

If Rodgers starts OK then hits a midseason slump the “…after starting strong in September, Rodgers struggles began as twilight became scarce, as the changing colors of the leaves signaled that they, like Rodgers would soon be moving on to something else.”

Or, if Rodgers, like Russell Wilson before him, should play well until fading down the stretch they’ll say, “….as Myles Garrett threw him down for a third and final time on the turf at Cleveland, the look on Rodgers’ face said it all, ‘he’d clearly wishes was spending the holidays in Malibu instead of Cleveland.’”

And this will happen independent of what comes out of Rodgers’ mouth. Rest assured, the slightest stray comment that even hits at a smidge of frustration on Rodger’s part will be magnified 10 times over to fit the “Rodgers wishes he’d retired instead of playing” narrative.

You’d better believe that commentators such as Mike Jones, Andrew Fillipponi and Tim Benz have this quote bookmarked, and will trot as soon as an opportunity presents itself.

So be it.

3. Consider the Alternative

Imagine, for a moment, if had Rodgers stated his plan was to play for several more seasons.

  • The reaction would have been just as swift and probably far more harsh.

You can easily imagine the leads along the lines of, “…after three years of wandering in the wilderness following Ben Roethlisberger’s retirement, the franchise continues to refuse to pull off the band aid and embrace renewal.”

Ben Roethlisberger, Art Rooney II, Roethlisberger final game Heinz Field, Steelers vs Browns

Art Rooney II and Ben Roethlisberger embrace. Photo Credit: Steelers.com, Karl Roser

And that’s only how the immediate narrative would have gone before Rodgers has taken his first snap. You can imagine how it would have evolved once the Steelers begin hitting stumbling blocks.

4. A Potential Upside to It All

At the end of the day, this was a question Aaron Rodgers was going to get, and it says here he gave the right answer. Yes, it is certainly possible that, if things get tough, if say, Troy Fautanu fails to stay healthy and/or Broderick Jones doesn’t develop and Rodgers takes a pounding he’ll regret his decision.

  • But if we know anything about Aaron Rodgers, its that he’s a competitor.

So when he says this is probably his final year, he’s most likely signaling that he’s planning on leaving it all out on the field.

And that is something Steelers Nation should welcome.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Steelers 2025 Draft Needs @ Offensive Line – Higher Than You Think….

The first big ticket free agent signing by Omar Khan and Andy Weidl was Isaac Seumalo. A few weeks later they made Broderick Jones their first round draft pick. A year later, they drafted Troy Fautanu in the first round, Zach Frazier in the 2nd round and Mason McCormick in the 4th round.

  • Sense a trend here?

But does that mean the Steelers could look again to the offensive line in 2025? Or might that just be too much of a good thing?

Broderick Jones

Broderick Jones decked out in color rush. Photo Credit: Karl Roser, Steelers.com

Steelers Offensive Line Depth Cart: The Starters

As the intro suggested, the Steelers brain trust has been very deliberate in building their offensive line. Alas, even though the Steelers have gotten what they’ve wanted in free agency and the draft, they yet to secure what they’ve needed.

The Steelers drafted Jones as a project, and played to bring him along and hopefully work him in at left tackle during 2023. Yet Chuks Okorafor struggled, and Jones had to replace him as a starter.

Last summer, the idea was for Jones to beat out Dan Moore at left tackle during training camp, for Fautanu to start at right tackle with Moore playing the swing tackle. But…

  • Moore showed he couldn’t play right tackle
  • Jones really wasn’t beating him out at left tackle anyway
  • Fautanu kept getting hurt, first in camp, and then after his only start

In a similar vein, the Steelers arrived at St. Vincents hoping to give Fraizer and McCormick apprenticeships at center and guard. Nick Herbig got injured early in camp, forcing Frazier into that role. And James Daniels was lost early in the season forcing McCorrmick into the starting role.

On paper, the Steelers should field a pretty strong offensive line in 2025…

…But as we’ve just seen, things haven’t been going according to plan.

Steelers Offensive Line Depth Chart: The Backups

In 2024, the Steelers successfully weathered so many offensive line injuries because they had good depth here. But now James Daniels, Dan Moore and Nick Herbig are playing elsewhere.

The Steelers do have Ryan McCollum who played well in two starts last season. Spencer Anderson has position flexibility and has played 25 NFL games including 4 starts at guard last season. The team also has offensive tackle Calvin Anderson whom they late in 2024 and Dylan Cook who spent 2023 on the Steelers active roster, who spent time on IR in 2024 as well as the practice squad.

For the record, the Steelers also list Doug Nester, Lecitus Smith and Steven Jones as guards on their off season roster.

The Steelers 2025 Draft Needs @ Offensive Line

This is where things get interesting. ON paper the Steelers starting offensive line appears set. Yet, when asked to commit to his front five at the NFL owners meeting, Mike Tomlin declined, explaining:Pittsburgh Steelers, NFL Draft, Pittsburgh Steelers Draft Needs Scale

I feel like we have some guys that are certainly capable of the role. But to say that as I sit here today, would be untrue. I don’t know who I’m going to end up with or who I’m going to be in position to consider.

It would be easy to write this off as just coach speak, but at the NFL Scouting Combine Steel City Insider’s Jim Wexell talked to “a league scout who knows the Steelers well” who cited Jones’ lack of development in 2024 labeling him a “coach killer.”

Given those comments, along with the absence of a true swing tackle and lack of depth at guard, and the Steelers needs at offensive line going into the 2025 NFL Draft must be considered High.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Free Agency: Should the Steelers Seek More of Dan Moore?

Rebuilding an offensive line on the fly is never advisable. Alas, sometimes in the NFL it is necessary. The Pittsburgh Steelers found themselves doing just that after the 2020 season saw them turnover 4/5ths of their offensive line in a single off season.

Three seasons later one player from that oft-maligned 2021 team remains. His name is Dan Moore and now he’s a free agent.

Should the Steelers be seeking more of Moore in 2025 and perhaps beyond?

Dan Moore, Steelers vs Titans,

Dan Moore Jr. heads of Arden Key at Acrisure Stadium. Photo Credit: Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Profile of Dan Moore’s Steelers Career

With the decline in play and subsequent departure of Alejandro Villanueva, the Steelers needed to act fast to fill their left tackle position. They did so in the 4th round of the 2021 NFL Draft when they took Dan Moore.

Dan Moore “won” the starting job in training camp (who else was going to play) and has started 66 of a possible 67 games since then, clocking in at 99, 100, 95 and 100 percent of the offensive snaps. While Pro Football Focus stats are anything but Gospel, the site did rate him at 46th out of 141 tackles rated in 2024.

The Case for the Steelers Resigning Dan Moore

Omar Khan traded up to draft Broderick Jones in 2023 and then drafted Troy Fautanu in the first round of 2024, so the Steelers resigning Dan Moore isn’t even theoretically possible, right? Not so fast.

While no one is confusing Dan Moore as the next Tony Boselli, he has improved every year. And if Pro Football Focus rating him in the top 1/3 of NFL tackles might not quite pass the “eye test,” he’s clearly a competent and capable NFL left tackle.

Broderick Jones has only played left tackle for a few quarters against Houston in 2023 and is still seen as a raw talent that’s in development. At least that’s the positive spin. One scout for a team other than the Steelers described Broderick Jones as a “coach killer.”

The problem is that Fautanu was injured through most of training camp and got injured in practice after his only start. And he had injury concerns coming into the draft. While signing Dan Moore to a long term contract may not be on the table, keeping him in Pittsburgh via the franchise or perhaps transition tag would be wise.

Kevin Colbert did that with Max Starks going into the 2008 season even though the Steelers had Marvel Smith and Willie Colon set as their starters. Smith got hurt against Jacksonville, Starks started the next week in Baltimore and continued to start all the way through Super Bowl XLIII.

Does that mean keeping Dan Moore in Pittsburgh will bring the Steelers to the Super Bowl in 2025?

Hardly. But it does reinforce the lesson that you can never have enough good offensive lineman. Especially when you’ve got existential questions about your presumptive starter at left tackle.

The Case Against the Steelers Resigning Dan Moore

That Max Starks-Dan Moore analogy sure stirs up feelings of nostalgia, doesn’t it? Nostalgia is nostalgia precisely because it’s a longing for things whose time has passed. The 2025 franchise tag for an offensive lineman is $23,402,000. The transition tag is “only” $21,271,000.

Dan Moore has developed into a serviceable starter-capable NFL left tackle – and that’s an accomplishment.

  • But are you really going to cut a 23 million dollar check for one-year Dan Moore rental?

The Steelers have a desperate needs at defensive line, wide receiver and cornerback and, oh yeah, they’ve got to sign a quarterback and neither Russell Wilson or Justin Fields is returning at the K-Mart Blue Light Special discount he played on last year.

The Steelers didn’t just bring Jones and Fautanu to Pittsburgh to start, they drafted them as “foundational pieces.” It is time for the offensive line to sink or swim with those two.

Curtain’s Call on the Steelers and Dan Moore

The idea of bringing back Dan Moore as an insurance policy is appealing. It may seem outlandish to write a large such a large check for a guy whom you’re projecting to sit on the bench, but the Steelers did it with Max Starks.

But the difference is Max Starks had already started Super Bowl XL. Dan Moore isn’t a Super Bowl starter. Moore can’t play both tackle positions. Starks could. The 2008 Steelers didn’t need to add starting-level talent at cornerback, wide receiver and on the defensive line. The 2025 Steelers do.

  • So using one of the tags on Dan Moore isn’t feasible.

And without the transition or franchise tag holding him back, Dan Moore has every incentive to test the free agent market, and he has every expectation that he should get starter’s money there.

Dan Moore has had a respectable career in Pittsburgh, but this is one player who’ll likely find that the grass is greener on the other side of free agency’s fence.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

5 Keys to the Steelers Success in the 2nd Half of the 2024 Season

The Pittsburgh Steelers exit the bye week with a 6-2 record and embark upon a brutal 9-game stretch that includes all 6 of their AFC North games including one Thursday night game and another Wednesday night game.

These games will put the Steelers through a crucible, testing them as they haven’t been tested before.

  • Steelers won’t win all of those games.

How well they pass this test will determine whether this team not only reaches the playoffs but whether they arrive there with a chance to make a run at Lombardi Number 7. (Please spare me the “win a playoff game mantra.”)

Here are X keys to for the Steelers success in the 2nd half of the season. Quick note: things like “Keep T.J. Watt and Cam Heyward healthy” are not “keys” as those are out of Mike Tomlin’s control.

Russell Wilson, Russell Wilson first start Steelers, Steelers vs Jets

Russell Wilson rolls out in his first start with the Steelers. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune-Review

1. Lean In to Arthur Smith’s Offense

For the first six games, Arthur Smith’s offense didn’t look much different than Matt Canada’s. Yes, Smith’s differences in philosophy were evident, but offense’s biggest weapons were Chris Boswell’s leg and Justin Fields legs.

When Russell Wilson took the helm against the Jets, a different offense began to emerge.

Wilson’s “Moon Balls” to George Pickens, Calvin Austin and Pat Freiermuth did more than just create “chunk” plays for the Steelers offense, it opened up rushing lanes for Najee Harris and Jaylen Warren.

This must continue. The Steelers are going to need a dynamic offense to prevail in the AFC North.

Calvin Austin, Steelers vs Giants,

Calvin Austin hauls in a touchdown. Photo Credit: Chaz Palla, Tribune-Review

2. Improve in the Red Zone

One thing that the Steelers offense hasn’t done appreciably better with Wilson at the help is score in the Red Zone. They did a little better in his first start against the Jets, but settled for field goals twice against the Giants, which transformed what should have been a blow out into a close game.

3. Beef Up the Run Defense

This need goes hand-in-hand with the offensive needs. If the Steelers execute Smith’s offense effectively, they’ll control the clock. But controlling the clock doesn’t really work if you settle for field goals instead of touchdowns.

One of the reasons that the Steelers can’t afford to keep settling for field goals is that it allows other teams to run the ball.

  • And the Steelers have struggled to stop the run – at times.

When the Chargers came into Acrisure, all eyes were on J.K. Dobbins and one of the NFL’s most vaunted rushing attacks. Yet the Steelers shut them down. Yet…

This is priority A 1 for Teryl Austin. Whether it means using the nickel defense less, playing Elandon Roberts more, coaching Patrick Queen to cover his gaps better or snapping Keeanu Benton out of a sophomore slump, he has to figure it out.

4. Continue to Build Cohesion on the Offensive Line

Once again the Steelers offensive line started slowly, but this time we know why: Injuries.

Everyone one of the training camp projected starters not named Dan Moorehas missed time, with Nate Herbig, James Daniels and Troy Fautanu lost for the season.

Given that the line has held its own, but it will need to do more than that on the back-end of the season. One player who clearly must step up is Broderick Jones. A year ago Jones earned his first start at left tackle against the Titans and that sparked the beginning of the turn around for the offensive line.

In 2024 he’s struggled at times. There is no doubt that injuries hampered him in the summer and early part of the year, but injuries or naught, the Steelers need better play from Jones during these last nine games.

5. Find a Way to Unleash Minkah Magic

Minkah Fitzpatrick has had a quiet season. That doesn’t mean he has played poorly. In fact, he’s done a good job of manning the back door and keeping a lid on the opposing offenses.

But to neutralize the likes of Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow and Lamar Jackson and the Steelers are going to need him to be a playmaker again.

 

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

What to Make of the Steelers “Maginot” Offensive Line?

The Pittsburgh Steelers are set to kickoff their celebration of the 1974 Super Bowl IX championship team at half time when the New York Jets come to Acrisure Stadium for Sunday Night football.

  • As Tony Dungy noted on Instagram, there’s a historical parallel emerging in real time.

In week 7 of the 1974 season Chuck Noll benched Joe Gilliam who was 4-1-1 in favor of the veteran Terry Bradshaw. And here in week 7 in 2024, all indicators point to Mike Tomlin benching Justin Fields, who is 4-2 as a starter, in favor of veteran Russell Wilson.

James Daniels, James Daniels guardian cap

James Daniels at Acrisure Stadium. Photo Credit: Kylee Surike, PennLive.com

That’s a great story and an awesome piece of historical symmetry that – God willing – will sustain itself through February.

But a tweet from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Gerry Dulac has me reaching further back into history for another parallel.

 

Will we remember 2024 as the year the Maginot Line reached Pittsburgh?

The Maginot Line in 88 Words

World War I was fought in muddy trenches in Northern and Eastern France. Determined to avoid a repeat, France spent 3.9 billion dollars building the Maginot Line along the German border.

The Maginot Line featured the best weapons and best fortification that money could buy, including air conditioning and its own subway.

But for all its bells and whistles, the Maginot Line was a complete failure. When Germany attacked in 1940 it went around, over or otherwise ignored France’s border defenses, securing victory in a few short weeks.

The Backstory Behind the Steelers 2024 Offensive Line

For a good chunk of the teens the Steelers had the best offensive line in the business. Then a combination of age, injury and Salary Cap Armageddon forced them to rebuild overnight.

Between the playoff loss against Cleveland in 2020 and opening day 2021 the Steelers fielded 4 new starters on offensive line. But rebuilding on the fly on the cheap didn’t work. Dan Moore is the only starter from that 2021 opening-day offensive line that remains.

Since then, Mike Tomlin, Kevin Colbert and Omar Khan have invested heavily in the offensive line. And they’re playing the long game in both free agency and the draft

James Daniels, 2022 free agent signing
Nate Herbig, 2023 free agent signing
Isaac Seumalo, 2023 free agent signing

Broderick Jones, First round draft pick 2023 NFL Draft
Troy Fautanu, First round draft pick 2024 NFL Draft
Zach Fraizer, 2nd round draft pick, 2024 NFL Draft
Mason McCormick, 4th round draft pick 2024 NFL Draft

The plan was for the line was to be rock that offensive coordinator Arthur Smith built is Bill Cowheresque offensive around.

But the Steelers will take the field against the Jets with Daniels, Herbig, Fautanu on injured reserve, Frazier out with an injury, Broderick Jones playing with an injured elbow, Seumalo starting just his third game due to injury and McCormick starting for Daniels.

So yes it does feel like Khan and company have built the football equivalent of the Maginot line in Pittsburgh. But that feeling is where the analogy should end.

The Maginot Line is a textbook example of a country preparing for the last war instead of the next one. In contrast, investing in the offensive line is always a sound strategy in football, at any level.

The Steelers have just has an incredibly bad streak of luck in terms of injuries on the offensive line.

  • But that hardly dooms the Terry Bradshaw-Russell Wilson parallel.

The last time the Steelers had to rebuild their offensive line in season was 2008.  It did not go smoothly, but it did end with Ben Roethlisberger holding the Lombardi on the dais after Super Bowl XLIII asking, “Offensive line, who’s laughing now?”

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Russell Wilson vs. Justin Fields – The Pros and Cons for Both as the Steelers Starter

Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin made it official at his press conference declaring that Russell Wilson is “in consideration” to start Sunday against the New York Jets at Acrisure Stadium.

Russell Wilson entered the preseason as QB Number 1, but injured his calf on the first day of drills at St. Vincents, leading Justin Fields to start for the Steelers first two preseason games. Wilson did start the final preseason game, but injured his calf the week before the season opener and Fields has started since.

This is an interesting call, as each quarterback brings pros and cons to the table. IT will also reveal something about Mike Tomlin.

Russell Wilson, Justin Fields,

Pittsburgh Steelers quarterbacks Russell Wilson (3) and Justin Fields (2) before a preseason game against Detroit Lions at Ford Field in Detroit on Saturday, August 24, 2024.

The Case for Justin Fields

The Pittsburgh Steelers are 4-2 with Justin Fields as their starting quarterback.

No, Fields hasn’t looked like the next Steve Young or Lamar Jackson. But he’s led the Steelers to four wins despite an offensive line that has been ravaged by injuries, a running game that’s been slow to start and what could be charitably described as a JV wide receiver crops, George Pickens excluded.

  • If Fields arrived in Pittsburgh as a quarterback reclamation project.

And no, he hasn’t looked like a late-blooming quarterback blossoming into an All Pro in real time. But there have been flashes that he is capable of greatness. Moreover, after throwing 30 interceptions over three seasons in Chicago, he’s thrown only one in Pittsburgh.

On our final point there is no room for equivocation: Justin Fields has been the most potent, most consistent weapon for the Steelers offense. He’s rushed for just under a third of their ground attack and scored 45% of their touchdowns.

The Case for Russell Wilson

The Steelers signed Russell Wilson to be their starter. This was the plan from the get go. His injury complicated things but since then he’s only been a question of WHEN and not IF.

  • Russell Wilson is a 9 time Pro Bowler and owns a Super Bowl ring.

The Steelers offense is young. Very young. Wilson will provide immediate veteran leadership in the huddle. That’s no knock on Fields, but Wilson has “been there, done that.”

If the wins over the Falcons, Broncos, Chargers and Raiders are any indication, the Steelers have a Super Bowl-ready defense. The offense has just been good enough to get by. It lacks explosiveness. It hasn’t made the “cunk” plays off of play action that Arthur Smith is known for.

Wilson can bring that. Even a bad situation last year in Denver, Wilson managed to throw 26 touchdown passes.

The Steelers haven’t sniffed that kind of areal attack since Ben Roethlisberger retired. The rough part of the Steelers schedule is rapidly approaching. Now is the time for Mike Tomlin and company to see exactly what they have in Wilson.

The Case Against Justin Fields

Yes, Fields has been the offense’s best weapon, but quarterbacks are supposed to do damage with their arms, not their legs.

  • And Fields hasn’t been a prolific passer.

Early in the season, Fields was taking shots down the field. but those have tapered off. Against the Raiders the Steelers leading receiver was George Pickens with 3 passes for 53 yards. 31 of those came in a late game stats padding play. Against the Cowboys, the Steelers leading ball catcher was Najee Harris who had 2 grabs for 35 yards.

  • Those are Pop Warner level stats, not NFL numbers.

And while its true that Fields has protected the ball, he has had 6 fumbles. He’s only lost one of those, but any of the others could have been game changers. He also had an ugly interception erased by a questionable penalty.

The Steelers have seen what they have in Fields. He’s someone they should consider keeping around next season. But the Steelers need more now.

The Case Against Russell Wilson

How about these numbers: 28, 6 and 12. That’s 28 preseason snaps for Russell Wilson, in 6 series, where he threw 12 passes. Yes, Russell Wilson is a decorated NFL veteran.

  • But he’s new to the team and new to the system.

And practice still makes perfect, and Wilson has only had a couple of three weeks in working as a full participant with the Steelers first team – and that goes back to the first week at St. Vincents.

And let’s keep in mind that the offensive line the Steelers were hoping to field when they arrived in Latrobe is very different from the one that will line up on Sunday night against the Jets. Troy Fautanu and James Daniels are in IR. Rookie Zach Frazier, arguably their best player already, will also be out.

While its true that many of Justin Fields runs have been designed plays, he’s also used his legs to evade the pass rush that the line has been powerless to stop. Can the Steelers really expect to put a 35-year-old man behind that line an hope to win?

While Russell Wilson might give the offense a boost, is he really going to make them Super Bowl contenders? Is it any easier to envision Van Jefferson mugging with the Lombardi than it was to imagine Weegie Thompson doing the same (nod to Defeo man)?

Justin Fields hasn’t proven he’s the next franchise quarterback for the Steelers, but he has shown that he might be. Its time for Mike Tomlin and Omar Khan to find out what they’ve really got.

Tomlin History with the Quarterback Carousel

Mike Tomlin might be the longest-tenured NFL coach, but hasn’t had much experience with quarterback management.

  • Ben Roethlisberger was going to be his starter no ifs, ands or buts.
Mitch Trubisky, Mason Rudolph, Kenny Pickett, Steelers 2022 quarterback competition

Mitch Trubisky, Kenny Pickett and Mason Rudolph. Photo Credit: Brandon Sloter / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images and The Athletic.)

During the 2010 preseason, he did stage 3 way competition between Byron Leftwich, Dennis Dixon and Charlie Batch. Tomlin took heat in the press for how he managed things, but the Steelers finished 3-1 during that stretch while effectively playing their 4th string quarterback.

That did not go as well. While his preference based on contract and draft status for Tribusiky and Pickett made sense, but the end of 2023 Mason Rudolph was looking liked he’d been the best quarterback all along.

Now Tomlin has to make another quarterback decision. Hopefully he’s gained wisdom through past experience.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

James Daniels Achilles Tear Offers Painful Reminder: You Can Never Have “Too Many” Good Offensive Lineman

For those of you just tuning in, the conclusion from the Steelers loss to the Colts was simple: Don’t jump to any. And that’s because Steelers last two trips to Indianapolis told us nothing about the trajectory of the team and because despite making a raft of mistakes, Pittsburgh still could have pulled off a win.

James Daniels, James Daniels guardian cap

James Daniels at Acrisure Stadium. Photo Credit: Kylee Surike, PennLive.com

But James Daniels’ Achilles tear and loss for the season did reinforce another reality about the game: The law of averages retains an awesome and oftentimes terrible ability to work its will in the NFL.

  • This is something that sports fans in general and Steelers fans in particular lose sight of.

It is easy to understand Steelers Nation’s collective shortsightedness. The Steelers have only had one losing season this century. Since Franco Harris consummated the Immaculate Reception, the worst the Steelers have done are 5-11 in 1988 and a trio of 6-12 seasons in 1986, 1999 and 2003.

Even without bringing those 6 Lombardi’s back to Pittsburgh, Dan Rooney found a way to beat the odds. But as James Daniels’ injury reminds us, even the Steelers do not enjoy immunity from the law of averages.

Both the Steelers offense and the offensive line have seen their share of ups and downs over the last two seasons. They’ve gotten off to slow starts in both seasons, complicating the development/the ability to evaluate the development of players like Kenny Pickett and Najee Harris.

  • But the units have been incredibly healthy during that time.

Dan Moore missed the Houston game in 2023, and there’ve been a few other dings here and there, but for the last two years the Steelers string of luck when it comes to the health of their offensive line has been remarkable and almost unprecedented.

  • But 2024 tells a different tale.

Going into training camp the smart money put the Steelers opening day offensive line as Dan Moore, Isaac Seumalo, Zach Frazier, James Daniels and Troy Fautanu. Within minutes of the opening gun at Indianapolis, the Steelers only Moore and Fraizer were playing.

The Steelers will hopefully get back Isaac Seumalo this week, but Daniels and Fautanu. are done for the year. That’s just the brutal reality of life in the NFL.

And that’s another reason why fans should maintain a Reality Football perspective on roster management and avoid indulging fantasy football fantasies.

Case in point, in mid-August fans on Steel City Insider’s South Side message board, a place for “adult” Steelers discussions if there ever was way, spent a lot of time debating a hypothetical James Daniels trade. And the debate wasn’t on whether Omar Khan should deal him, but how much Khan could get for him.

It was as if we’d forgotten the musical chairs on offensive line in 2021 that involved John Leglue and “The General” Joe Haeg.

Fortunately none of that reached the ears of Omar Khan or Andy Weidl. Both men have been around the block long enough to know that the corollary to the Law of Averages is this: In the NFL, you can NEVER have enough good offensive lineman.

James Daniels has been a good player for the Steelers, a leader on the offensive line and by all accounts is a stand up guy in the locker room. Here’s to wishing him good luck and Godspeed on his recovery from a difficult and painful injury.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.

Muuth! Steelers Resign Pat Freiermuth to 5 Year Contract, End Negotiations Until Spring

Muuth! You’d better get used to hearing that one, as the Steelers have resigned tight end Pat Freiermuth. This is Freiermuth’s second contract which essentially tears up the final year on his rookie deal and adds four more years to the tune of 49.88 million dollars, or 48.4 than he was set to earn on his current contract.

The Steelers drafted Freiermuth out of Penn State in the second round of the 2021 NFL Draft. Since then he has logged 155 receptions for 1537 yards including 3 touchdowns. Since his arrival in Pittsburgh, Freiermuth has been one of the most consistent members of the Steelers offense, despite having a down year in 2023, when injuries limited him to 32 catches and just 2 touchdowns.

Pat Freiermuth, Steelers vs. Browns,

Focused Pat Freiermuth scores the go ahead touchdown. Photo Credit: Karl Roser, Steelers.com

However, offensive coordinator Arthur Smith’s new scheme has been described as “tight end centric” and it would seem to favor Frierermuth. The Steelers were expected to resign Freiermuth, but the 5 year length of his contract amounts to a bit of a surprise given his concussion history. Freiermuth suffered two concussions as a rookie and a third during his second season.

Steelers Done with Contracts Until January

The Steelers signed Cam Heyward earlier in the week and with Freiermuth’s deal signed, Omar Khan will put all contract wheeling and dealing on ice until the off season. Since 1993 the Steelers have had a no-negotiation policy during the regular season and that will likely continue as long as the Rooneys control the team.

There had been speculation – although that may have just been fans wanting this to happen as opposed to any seriously sourced reports — that the Steelers might resign Jaylen Warren, but that will not happen now.

Freiermuth is the first member of the Steelers 2021 draft class to get a second contract, and he may very well be the only one. Najee Harris is a free agent, and did not have his 5th year option picked up. With Broderick Jones and Troy Fautanu working on rookie deals, Dan Moore is unlikely to get a second contract from the Steelers, although he is their best tackle at this point.

Isaiahh Loudermilk is the only other member of that draft class left on the team.

Finally, by waiting days before the season opener, Omar Khan has reverted to following Kevin Colbert’s policy of holding off on signing deals until the end of the summer. During his first two years as general manager, Khan inked new contracts with Diontae Johnson, Minkah Fitzpatrick and Chris Boswell in July.

It will be interesting to see if this pattern continues in the summer of 2025.

Please lend a hand by sharing this on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp etc... Thanks.